Federal Judge Blocks Henryetta From Prosecuting Tribal Citizens

Federal Judge Blocks Henryetta From Prosecuting Tribal Citizens

A federal judge has ruled the City of Henryetta must stop prosecuting Native Americans for municipal offenses inside Muscogee Nation reservation boundaries, marking a major development in ongoing tribal jurisdiction battles across Oklahoma.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Jason A. Robertson issued the preliminary injunction Wednesday in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Oklahoma.

The ruling temporarily blocks Henryetta from issuing or enforcing municipal criminal citations against Native Americans for alleged violations occurring within city limits.

According to the federal court opinion, the dispute centers on longstanding federal law and treaty obligations involving the Muscogee Nation.

Federal Judge Says Tribal Jurisdiction Is Matter of Law

Judge Robertson wrote that the case involving tribal jurisdiction does not create new legal boundaries but instead enforces authority already established by Congress and federal treaties.

“This injunction draws no new line,” Robertson wrote. “It enforces the one Congress already drew.”

The Muscogee Nation originally filed the lawsuit in July 2025, arguing Henryetta continued prosecuting Native Americans despite the U.S. Supreme Court’s landmark McGirt v. Oklahoma decision.

According to the court filing, tribal officials claimed the city refused to negotiate cross-deputization agreements and ignored repeated concerns involving jurisdiction authority.

Henryetta Arguments Rejected by Federal Court

Attorneys for Henryetta argued the U.S. Supreme Court’s Oklahoma v. Castro-Huerta ruling expanded state authority inside Indian Country and supported municipal prosecutions.

Judge Robertson rejected that argument, ruling that municipalities cannot independently exercise criminal authority over tribal citizens without congressional authorization.

“If the state lacks authority to prosecute Indians in Indian Country absent congressional authorization, the city necessarily lacks it as well,” Robertson wrote.

The ruling specifically blocks Henryetta from prosecuting Native Americans for traffic offenses, misdemeanors, and municipal code violations while the lawsuit continues.

State Leaders Criticize Tribal Jurisdiction Ruling

Muscogee Nation Principal Chief David Hill praised the ruling, saying the court correctly upheld federal law and treaty obligations.

Meanwhile, Governor Kevin Stitt’s office sharply criticized the decision.

According to Gov. Stitt’s press secretary Tevis Hillis, the governor believes Oklahoma laws should apply equally to all residents regardless of race and expects appeals to continue.

Judge Robertson also pointed to successful cross-deputization agreements already operating between tribal and local agencies elsewhere within eastern Oklahoma reservation boundaries, including the City of Coweta.

The broader tribal jurisdiction dispute continues unfolding across Oklahoma federal courts as multiple cases tied to the McGirt decision remain active.

source:NonDoc (Reporter, Derrick James)

*Rewritten for SEO and clarity

🔴 MORE RADIO NEWS