OOPS! Coal County Sheriff Still on Duty Despite Suspension Vote

Coal County Sheriff Still on Duty After Suspension Vote Turns Out Legally Invalid

Commissioners' Suspension Vote Carries No Legal Authority

Coal County officials are facing an embarrassing situation after county commissioners voted to suspend Sheriff Jason Smith and Undersheriff Jesse Yother — only to learn they did not have the authority to do so.

According to Oklahoma law, only a district judge can suspend an elected official. That means both Smith and Yother remain in their positions despite last month’s indictment on multiple criminal charges.

District Attorney Chuck Sullivan acknowledged the mistake, calling the commissioners' action an “embarrassing oversight” and emphasizing that proper legal procedures must be followed.

Criminal Charges Still Moving Forward

Sheriff Jason Smith faces charges of domestic assault and battery, while Undersheriff Yother is charged with felony intimidation of a witness and misdemeanor obstruction.

Both have denied wrongdoing. Their attorneys will appear in court on February 6, when a judge will determine whether a trial will proceed and whether suspension is warranted.

Confusion Leaves County in Limbo

The failed suspension vote has created uncertainty for Coal County residents, many of whom expected the sheriff’s office to be temporarily reassigned.

Until a judge makes a ruling, Smith and Yother remain legally permitted to continue working, though it is unclear how active they will be in their roles given the pending charges.

Legal experts say the incident highlights how complex — and often misunderstood — Oklahoma’s statutes are when it comes to removing or suspending elected officials.

🔻📌 MORE RADIO NEWS