Oklahoma Supreme Court Reprimands Special Judge for Bias, Poor Conduct

 Judicial Misconduct Officially Acknowledged

The Oklahoma Supreme Court has issued a public reprimand to Special Judge Emily Mueller, who presides over proceedings in Pottawatomie and Lincoln Counties. The reprimand identifies evidence of bias toward certain attorneys and a generally poor demeanor toward courthouse staff.

Judge’s Response Cites Personal Habits

During investigative interviews, Mueller attributed her behavior to personal scheduling preferences — noting that she was "not a morning person." The Supreme Court found her explanation insufficient, stating that courtroom conduct and staff treatment must remain professional regardless of personal factors.

Broader Implications for Judicial Oversight

• Erosion of Trust: Bias and unprofessional behavior by judges can damage credibility and fairness in the court system.

• Need for Training: The reprimand underscores the importance of judicial training in ethics and courtroom professionalism, particularly for part-time or special judges.

• Public Record: A public reprimand ensures transparency and accountability, signaling that these matters are taken seriously by the state’s highest court.